Since January, 2003

Ad by HillAds
 (a random before-and-after moment)
November 24, 2006
October 19, 2014
Half at I, Looking East-Southeast (see more)

Today the Historic Preservation Review Board voted unanimously to support the recommendation of preservation office staff, rejecting the historic landmark application for the Market Deli on the northeast corner of 1st and L streets, SE.
The staff recommendation seemed to be the primary driver of the board members' votes (with most board members having little comment on the application beyond "I support the staff recommendation"). Its author, Tim Dennee, reiterated its main points in his testimony, saying that while it would have been a good idea to keep the building maintained, the lack of underlying historic merit beyond the building representing the other old structures in the neighborhood that are gone does not allow the Market Deli to rise to the level of a landmark. There was also a lot of discussion about how the neighborhood "context" that would have allowed for a better understanding of the Deli's place in the history of the area is already gone, with so many buildings having already been demolished.
Testifying in the support of the nomination was ANC 6D07 rep David Garber, who said he ran for the position because "there's such a clear opportunity in this neighborhood to develop something great." He described himself as "100 percent in favor of development in most cases," but feels that the Market Deli represents a "common building type for common people" and that "what's remarkable about the Market Deli is that it's unremarkable." Also testifying was Hayden Wetzel, who said he prepared at the application at Garber's request and who echoed Garber's comments by saying that it's a "sweet and pretty little building" and that the "ordinariness of the building speaks for itself." He said that he formed a task force within the DC Preservation League in 2000 to consider the buildings in the area, but that it didn't result in much interest.
Six people testified in opposition: three residents, Dodd Walker of Akridge (the owners of the building), Michael Stevens of the BID, and a woman hired by Akridge (whose name and affiliation I unfortunately missed) to investigate the building's history. Much of what was said by the residents, Stevens, and Walker were variations on comments made the ANC meeting and in the Memorandum in Opposition that was presented to the board with 39 co-signers. With concerns about how an ANC's position is given "great weight," resident Kitty Loyd focused her testimony on the ANC vote a few weeks ago, contending that Garber should have recused himself since he expressed an interest in saving this building before he became commissioner. (Loyd also apparently printed out the JDLand Market Deli comment threads to give to the board, so you're all famous.) Both Michael Stevens and resident Adam Hall mentioned their feelings that there wasn't enough of a public process followed by Garber in submitting this application, while Hall also said that the building "gives the neighborhood a dangerous feel" because of the neglect.
Stevens also took time to list all the historic buildings in the neighborhood that are still in existence (from the Navy Yard to the Blue Castle to the beaux arts WASA Pumping Plant to the buildings being redeveloped at the Yards, as well as the private homes and businesses along 3rd, K, L, Potomac, and lower 8th). He also mentioned the 10 to 12 years of planning and analysis (and studies) by city agencies starting in the late 90s that have gone into the remaking of Near Southeast, back before the demolition of so many properties--"would this history not have been discovered then?"
There was also a detailed (some might also describe it as "long") presentation from Akridge's historic preservation consultant about the history of the building, which apparently suffered a pretty serious fire in 1921 and appears to have been pretty well gutted at that time. Those who've never seen the interior of the Market Deli might be interested in seeing her presentation, which will be available when HPRB posts the video of the hearing sometime on Friday.
There were few questions during the hearing from the board members, and, in the end, only chair Catherine Buell seemed anything less than fully supportive of the staff recommendation. She called it a "tough case," and said that she would like to see preservation plans and multiproperty listings done for the area (beyond just the "windshield survey" done by the Office of Planning back around the time of the ballpark). But in the end, saying that she didn't think the building was eligible for landmark status and that the ANC's comments (which are to be given "great weight") didn't really speak to the board's criteria, she called for a vote, and the board voted unanimously.
This was followed by a quick secondary vote on the Deli: the raze permit application for the building was also on the agenda, in the event that the landmark application was approved. Because it wasn't, the board voted to support the staff recommendation that says the board no longer has jurisdiction over the property, and so the "city's issuance of a raze permit may proceed without further preservation review."
And that would seem to bring this matter to a close. Just after the hearing, Garber tweeted: "I'm glad there was a chance for discussion on the matter, and I look forward to helping approve new plans to bring vibrancy to the site."
Comments (13)
 
 More About meetings

JDLand.com Home

Comments

Charles says: (4/28/11 2:20 PM)
It should be noted that the meeting was held up for roughly 20 minutes so the HPRB could wait for the "applicant" to arrive.

In this case, the applicant was none other than David Garber.

So while his previous statements that he did not "submit" or "draft" the nomination might be technically correct, those who believed that David was the driving force behind this were proven right.

This point was hammered home when the gentleman from the DC Preservation society stated a the nomination was "prepared at the request of David Garber."



MJM says: (4/28/11 2:43 PM)
So six people showed up to fight the wood building - how many people showed up yesterday to say their piece to stay in Ward 6 instead of being added to Ward 8?

JD - I'm sure you'll post something about Market Deli (again) when the fences go up and local residents hold a pagan-type festival on 1st St celebrating the razing of that block followed by a trip to das beer garden at Half St? :)


Charles says: (4/28/11 2:43 PM)
Just when I think I am out, he pulls me back in...

With the bad - see above - comes the good - David's recent efforts on redistricting.

I know this post has nothing to do with the subject, I felt the need to give the man credit when credit is due.


Hoodie says: (4/28/11 2:50 PM)
Then why wasn't David at the redistricting hearing, as the neighborhood's elected representative, and as other 6D commissioners were?

Nice to be doing something now, but there's no excuse to not have been there. Barry's been making noises about annexing the west side of the waterfront for weeks.



MJM says: (4/28/11 3:13 PM)
I guess one was today and one was yesterday (unless it still on-going today) - my post wasn't connecting the two just saying wish there could have been more Near-Southeasters at the meetings where CM Barry's attempt to annex Cap Riverfront BID was taking place


Charles says: (4/28/11 3:25 PM)
MJM - I am afraid that I was so concentrated on an issue that should never have been an issue that I totally missed hearing about Barry's recent activities and the redistricting issues.

You are right. I should have been there.

Please feel free to email me (my info is on building link) if you would like to discuss what we might do moving forward.


Charles says: (4/28/11 3:26 PM)
Hoodie - I had no idea that David was not there and am deeply disappointed to find out he missed it. Whatever credit he earned for an email he forwarded are totally lost when he manages to miss the meeting.


F says: (4/28/11 3:42 PM)
The Market Deli fiasco is laid to rest. Lets move on to more important efforts; How to keep near SE out of the hands of barry.

Can anyone report from the redistricting meeting and provide some recommendations?


JD says: (4/28/11 3:53 PM)
You guys can move the redistricting chat to this thread: link


JT says: (4/28/11 4:48 PM)
Akridge should crowd-source the Market Deli demolition by charging neighbors for the chance to swing a sledgehammer.

They'd be able to finance their development of the block with the proceeds.


Jesse says: (4/28/11 5:08 PM)
Thank goodness the Market Deli was denied the historic designation. It's an eyesore and needs to be demolished to make way for new development. We can't afford to have this eyesore hanging around vacant for decades.

I often walk by the church at 4th Street and Virginia Ave. Talk about UGLY! The church needs to be razed pronto. It simply does not fit or mesh with the surrounding neighborhood. Get rid of the church and use the land to create a cute ittle park with a jungle gym and park benches. How nice would that be?



JD says: (4/28/11 5:12 PM)
Church has already been landmarked, Jesse. Not gonna happen.


Michael says: (4/28/11 8:39 PM)
Score for Big Real Estate Corporations and their lobbyists (the BID)...


Trulee Pist says: (4/28/11 10:37 PM)
Garber's appeal to HPRB might have carried more weight if he'd bothered to show up on time this morning. Dilettante Commissioner.


MJM says: (4/29/11 9:40 AM)
They were just starting to put the plastic up around 7:20 this morning - they aren't wasting time tearing that apart


JD says: (4/29/11 9:50 AM)
Here's a photo someone tweeted out: link

Add a Comment:

Comments are closed for this post.

JDLand Comments RSS Feed

See All Current News Items | Full Blog Archive

 
 Top News
  
Recent Comments:  
202_cyclist on Southeast Blvd.: I support Concepts A and B because DC desperately needs more housing. Additiona...
JD on Southeast Blvd.: I said this on Twitter a little while ago--I wouldn't be surprised if this has a...
Gamble Rogers on Southeast Blvd.: Totally agree with E. Masquinongy -- thanks for the great summary and links, JD....
JES on Free 'Fan Festival'/Fairgrounds: I would advocate for just closing half street to traffic between the metro and s...



City Government Data for Near Southeast Records added or updated recently displayed here; click the "archive" links to see additional detail and older records. All data from DC Government databases and RSS feeds. JDLand takes no responsibility for errors, omissions, etc. (read CapStat disclaimer). Data is retrieved daily.

Recent Crime Incidents Archive  
1200 B/O 1ST ST SE   THEFT
Theft F/Building
 12/08/14
1200 B/O 1ST ST SE   THEFT
 11/21/14
900 B/O 5TH ST SE   BURGLARY
 11/21/14
200 B/O I ST SE   THEFT
 11/21/14
1200 B/O NEW JERSEY AVE SE   THEFT
 11/20/14
900 B/O NEW JERSEY AVE SE   THEFT F/AUTO
 11/17/14

Active Public Space Permits Archive  
1331 2ND ST SE    Carlton Ray 
Assigned
paving; streetfixture; excavation  
 02/10/14
to
02/09/15
1331 4TH ST SE    Forest City Forest City 
Issued
excavation; new  
 01/10/14
to
02/10/15

Recent Issued Building Permits Archive  
1025 1ST ST SE   
12/03/14 
NA NA NA
EHOP1590134 / HOME OCCUPATION
   
12/10/14 
KAREN NZAKIMUENA
PC74349112 / POST CARD
INSTALLATION OF NOT MORE THAN 1 NEW AIR CONDITIONING UNIT UP TO A MAXIMUM OF 10-TONS OF EQUIVALENT REFRIGERATING EFFECT.
1016 3RD ST SE   
12/15/14 
ANAMARIA R MOTTOLA / DIXON
B1502438 / CONSTRUCTION
RENOVATIONS MINOR MEP
1212 4TH ST SE   
12/10/14 
FC 1212 LLC / SCHINDLER ELEVATOR CORP
ER1500593 / SHOP DRAWING
REPLACE MAXTON UC2A VALVE EST. COST OF WORK $ 2 2120. 00
927 5TH ST SE   
12/15/14 
AARON LORENZO
PC25919394 / POST CARD
REPLACEMENT IN KIND OF EXISTING FENCE ON PRIVATE PROPERTY. REPLACEMENT IN KIND WHEN APPLIED TO ARCHITECTURAL FEATURES MEANS REPLACEMENT WITH A FEATURE OF LIKE MATERIAL THAT REPLICATES THE EXISTING FEATURE IN PROPORTION APPEARANCE TEXTURE DESIGN DETAIL AND DIMENSIONS.
1000 5TH ST SE   
12/04/14 
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA / WALTER T JONES
E1501598 / SUPPLEMENTAL
1015 HALF ST SE   
12/10/14 
HALF STREET LLC / ART DISPLAY; BOB BIROONAK ART DISPLAY CO.
SG1400465 / CONSTRUCTION
ONE ILLUMINATED NEWS TICKER SIGN
1201 HALF ST SE   
12/10/14 
WEST HALF 1 LLC / MARK W GIBSON
E1501746 / SUPPLEMENTAL
   
12/12/14 
JASON YORK
TN1500036 / CONSTRUCTION
INSTALLING SMALL TENT ON DEC 29 2014 FOR THE BRIDGESTONE WINTER CLASSIC ON 1-1-15 WITH GENERATOR TENTS REMOVED ON 1-2-15
808 L ST SE   
12/10/14 
NAVY YARD ASSOCIATES LLC / KE-MAURELLE PREDDIE
B1412006 / CONSTRUCTION
NEW OFFICE USE FOR 1254 SQ. FT. EXISTING TWO STORIES PLUS BASEMENT STRUCTURE ON SE / C-3-A ZONING DISTRICT. MECHANICAL ELECTRICAL AND PLUMBING REMAIN AS IS.
80 M ST SE   
12/10/14 
WELLS REIT II 80 M STREET LLC / ANTHONY G SAMBURG
E1501724 / SUPPLEMENTAL
14 M ST SE   
12/16/14 
ROMAN CATHOLIC ARCHBISHOP OF WASHINGTON / PHILLIP B. MOBLEY
FB1500047 / SUPPLEMENTAL
20 M ST SE   
12/04/14 
TRANSWESTERN JEFFREY GROSS / OLLIE READ; TRANSWESTERN JEFFREY GROSS; CHRISTOPHER SCHULZE
AR66514546 / SUPPLEMENTAL
   
12/04/14 
TRANSWESTERN JEFFERY W GROSS / ANDREW ARNTSON; TRANSWESTERN JEFFERY W GROSS; ANDREW ARNTSON
P96600069 / SUPPLEMENTAL
80 M ST SE   
12/03/14 
MARY JACKSON
PC44081129 / POST CARD
REPLACEMENT OF NOT MORE THAN 1 GAS APPLIANCE ON A RESIDENTIAL COMMERCIAL OR INDUSTRIAL PROJECT.
   
12/05/14 
WELLS REIT II 80 M STREET LLC /
P1501746 / SUPPLEMENTAL
100 M ST SE   
12/03/14 
SQUARE 743 INC. / SAM HOLLEN RAMCO OF DC INC.
B1502037 / CONSTRUCTION
INTERIOR RENOVATION TO 4TH FLOOR OFFICE SPACE. SUBDIVIDE TENANT SPACE AND ADD PANTRY. PARTITIONS MEP AND LIFE SAFETY. NORTHWOOD INVESTORS LLC
202 M ST SE   
12/10/14 
DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA / WOODY WICKLIFFE
TN1500035 / CONSTRUCTION
INSTALL 50FT X 100FT TENT NO GENERATORS NO COOKING NO SMOKING NO STAGES 10FT X 70FT TENT INSTALLED DEC 11-15 2014 EVENTS DEC 12-14 2014 12:01PM - 9:00 PM
1201 M ST SE   
12/11/14 
CARLTON RAY
AH1500149 / CONSTRUCTION
TO PERFORM TEMPORARY LANE CLOSURES
75 N ST SE   
12/11/14 
CRANE SERVICE CO / CHRISTINE LONG
AH1500150 / CONSTRUCTION
AN AFTER HOURS PERMIT IS RESPECTFULLY REQUESTED FROM 2:00AM THRU 11:00PM
800 NEW JERSEY AVE SE   
12/08/14 
SQUARE 737 LLC / GLENNWOOD ROGERS
P1501673 / SUPPLEMENTAL
25 POTOMAC AVE SE   
12/02/14 
RIVERFRONT HOLDINGS I LLC C/O ECC INC. / ECC INC.
UT1500007 / CONSTRUCTION
REMOVAL OF ONE 100-GALLON UNDERGROUND STORAGE TANK DURING MASS EXCAVATION ACTIVITIES FOR SITE REDEVELOPMENT.
   
12/03/14 
RIVERFRONT HOLDINGS I LLC / WOODY WICKLIFFE
TN1500032 / CONSTRUCTION
INSTALL 40FT X 80FT TENT NO COOKING NO SMOKING NO PROPANE NO LIGHTING 40FT X 40FT TENT 2 GENERATORS 25KW EACH 20FT X 20FT TENT 8FT X 20FT PLATFORM 40FT X 40FT PLATFORM 20FT X 20FT PLATFORM INSTALLED DEC 8 -9 2014 EVENT DEC 9 2014 9AM - 4PM
   
12/05/14 
FLORIDA ROCK PROPERTIES INC / ROBERT S. WATTS
E1501658 / SUPPLEMENTAL
   
12/05/14 
RIVERFRONT INVESTMENT PARTNERS / JASON BENTLEY
B1408697 / CONSTRUCTION
CONSTRUCTION OF NEW 9 STORY BUILDING. THIRD PARTY REVIEW
300 TINGEY ST SE   
12/15/14 
FC BOILERMAKER LLC / GREGORY BIRCKHEAD; FC BOILERMAKER LLC; MICHAEL BELL
E55526822 / SUPPLEMENTAL
AH = After Hours; B = Alteration & Repair; D = Demolition; E = Electrical; FB = Boiler; M = Mechanical; P = Plumbing and Gas; PC = Post Card; R = Raze; SG = Sign; TL = Tenant Layout; TN = Tent; RW = Retaining Wall;

Real Property Sales Archive  
No commercial transaction records added or modified in the past two weeks.


Project Directory




Blog/Home
Project Directory
Photo Archive
Event Photos
 
Nats Park
Food Map
What's New
History

 
Demolished Buildings
Historic Photos
Satellite Images
Timeline
 
About JDLand
Message JD
Advertise
Photo Use
 
     © Copyright 2014 JD.