Since January, 2003
 (a random before-and-after moment)
July 20, 2004
March 28, 2015 
2nd (West) at I, Looking South-Southwest (see more)

Posted on Friday was the Staff Report from the Historic Preservation Review Board on the design for the proposed Bier Garden at 8th and L, SE, as the owners of the site at 720 L continue to work toward constructing a one-story building with an accompanying summer garden and roof deck. (You can look to the left, or see a slightly larger version of the design, as it was presented to ANC 6B last week; 6B voted to support the design.)
If you're not up for reading all six pages yourself, here's my Zagat-style report on the report:
It makes for good reading if you're interested in how new buildings in historic districts are evaluated; you might be surprised (I was!) that design guidelines actually "discourage the exact duplication of historic styles," opting instead to encourage applicants to consider a new building as an "enhancement" to the district "while respecting the historic context." The report discusses how the decision to go with a one-story structure could draw on "the vernacular of Washington's modest industrial buildings and alley warehouses," and in fact the report includes a photo of the Bier Garden lot in 1949, when a one-story building housing a laundry/tailor stood on the site.
The report finds that the proposed massing of the new building does reflect the character of the historic district and "references recognizable attributes" of both industrial buildings and traditional beer gardens. The report also sees the rain screen and other more contemporary design choices as reflecting the "whimsy, casualness and somewhat ad-hoc nature of many outdoor beer gardens."
However, there are concerns that there are so many finishes applied "in so many different directions" that the result is a "somewhat chaotic and unfinished appearance," and suggests selecting one or two key ideas that would allow the building "to be showcased in a less hectic manner." Other major issues cited include choices on the roof deck (and the lack of any lighting or shade up there in the current design), the proportions of the doors, and the designs of the rain screens, as well as how the building's "streetscape presence" along both 8th and L.
The report ends with a recommendation that the applicants "restudy the issues outlined [...] as they pertain to the principles of design cohesiveness, proportion and scale, and streetscape presence." It's also recommended that the board delegate final approval of the design to the board staff once the comments from staff and the board are addressed in the revisions.
The hearing begins at 10 am on Thursday, and can be watched live, or on demand starting the next day. (And this will actually be the first HPRB hearing I'll have ever watched!) You can read my previous Bier Garden posts if you're needing to get caught up.
UPDATE: And now we return back to "Beer Garden" from "Bier Garden," as Mark Brody informs me that it was a typo on the plans.
Comments (0)
 
 More About 8th Street

JDLand.com Home

Comments

Trulee Pist says: (2/21/11 3:24 PM)
From reading the HPRB staff report by the estimable Amanda Molson, I get the sense HPRB staff took a more professional approach to criticisms and endorsements of the concept than that taken by critics of the Beer Garden at the ANC6B hearing. I am glad ANC6B as well recommends HPRB approve this concept.

1. HPRB staff recommends approval of the site plan, endorsing as well the plan to "mush together" the two lots in question and the massing of the proposed buildings on the newly subdivided lot, and praises the developer and architect for being on the "right track" regarding the design of the rooftop deck. The JDLand/Zagat precis failed to mention those endorsements.

2. The HPRB staff likes the solid wall that screens off the rooftop deck, only they'd like to see the familiar "double cornice" projected molding that you see on the top of most CH buildings to define better where the first story ends and the roof deck wall begins. Also, HPRB staff finds the front door at the corner too big in height and width (on the contrary, misguided ANC6B critics went on and on and on about how they thought the door was "too stubby"), and would like to see a transom window over the 8th Street SE door (something the owner and architect already told ANC6B they'd be happy to add to the plans.)

3. HPRB staff would like to see more openings along the L Street SE wall, so passers-by can see that people in the ground level beer garden are drinking beer, swaying to the oompah music and generally having good, clean fun. That's a suggestion not made by ANC6B, but one I bet the developer will embrace.

4. HPRB staff would like the developer and architect to chill out with all the different materials and what HPRB felt was the excessive height over the 8th and L Street corner and at the northeast corner of the building and in the roofing over the outside staircase to the roof deck. Those are good suggestions and will require some work by the architect and developer to meet those objections. HPRB staff also objects that specific design plans for lighting and for sunscreening the roof deck should be included in the plans. I hope the architect and developer do make changes to meet those objections.

5. No silly talk about drunks falling off the roof, or dropping their drinks off the roof, or jumping up on the counters that hold patrons' drinks set up around the inside edge of the roof deck and also falling off the roof that way, like we heard at ANC6B's hearing. Will it be raining oompah-music-and-beer fans if this get built? Not likely.

I hope HPRB approves these concept drawings with few contingencies, and the project moves forward expeditiously.


Caphilldel says: (2/25/11 9:24 AM)
I heard from a reliable source yesterday that 720 L ST was sold & the bier/beer garden is a no go- (Please) Say it isn't so!!


JD says: (2/25/11 10:17 AM)
It's possible the rumor you're hearing is in reference to the two brown "apartment" buildings just to the west of 720 L, on the other side of the driveway curb cut, which I'm hearing (but haven't confirmed) have changed hands. Guess we'll see when the video from yesterday's HPRB meeting gets posted, since I imagine if the site was sold then the application would have been withdrawn. (I kind of doubt it, but we'll see.)

Add a Comment:

Comments are closed for this post.

JDLand Comments RSS Feed

See All Current News Items | Full Blog Archive

 

JDLand.com's Official Unofficial Guide, Updated for 2015!
 Top News
  
Recent Comments:  
202_cyclist on Photo Gallery: But will Joe Biden race Teddy and the rest of the presidents this year?
JNB on Bonchon Officially Opening: Went last night. It was awesome!!!
JD on Bonchon Officially Opening: Waiting for the weekend so I can go with Mr. JDLand, but given that we used to d...
SWag on Bonchon Officially Opening: I went to Bonchon last night. Wow! That's some good chicken! The hot is HOT! No ...



City Government Data for Near Southeast Records added or updated recently displayed here; click the "archive" links to see additional detail and older records. All data from DC Government databases and RSS feeds. JDLand takes no responsibility for errors, omissions, etc. (read CapStat disclaimer). Data is retrieved daily.

Recent Crime Incidents Archive  
0 B/O POTOMAC AVE SE   ROBBERY
Robbery/Attempt To Commit Robbery
 03/28/15
600 B/O VIRGINIA AVE SE   ROBBERY  03/22/15
300 B/O TINGEY ST SE   THEFT
2nd Degree
 03/22/15
500 B/O L ST SE   THEFT
Theft 1st Degree
 03/21/15
50 B/O M ST SE   THEFT
2nd Degree
 03/10/15
300 B/O L ST SE   MOTOR VEHICLE THEFT
Unauthorized Use Of Vehicle
 03/08/15
700 B/O L ST SE   ROBBERY
Robbery -- Force & Violence
 03/07/15
1300 B/O 4TH ST SE   THEFT
Theft 1 (Theft F/Building)
 03/02/15

Active Public Space Permits Archive  
No records added or modified in the past two weeks.

Recent Issued Building Permits Archive  
1233 1ST ST SE   
03/25/15 
BALLPARK HOTEL LLC / APS INSPECTIONS
B1403486 / CONSTRUCTION
THE SCOPE OF WORK FOR THE 1233 1ST ST SE SUBMISSION IS THE CORE AND SHELL ONLY OF A NEW 12 STORY BUILDING. THE APPROXIMATELY 127 200 SF BUILDING IS INTENDED TO BE A HOTEL. THE FUTURE INTERIOR FIT-OUT WILL BE SUBMITTED SEPARATELY. THE BUILDING WILL SIT ON TOP OF GROUND FLOOR RETAIL / LOBBY LEVEL SUBMITTED AS PART OF A SEPARATE SUBMISSION FOR 1277 1ST ST SE.
1277 1ST ST SE   
03/25/15 
BALLPARK RESIDENTIAL LLC / BALL PARK SQUARE LLC
B1403488 / CONSTRUCTION
THE SCOPE OF WORK FOR THE 1277 1ST ST SE SUBMISSION INCLUDES 2 LEVELS OF BELOW GRADE PARKING TOTALING 370-380 PARKING SPACES A GROUND FLOOR RETAIL / LOBBY / LOADING LEVEL WITH APPROXIMATELY 26 500 SF OF RETAIL AND AN APPROXIMATELY 304 000 SF 13 STORY APARTMENT BUILDING CONTAINING APPROXIMATELY 326 UNITS.
1299 1ST ST SE   
03/16/15 
BALL PARK SQUARE LLC / PHYLLIS STEVENS
B1403487 / CONSTRUCTION
THE SCOPE OF WORK FOR THE 1299 1ST ST SE SUBMISSION IS THE CORE AND SHELL OF A NEW APPROXIMATELY 7 600 SF 2 STORY RETAIL BUILDING WITH A SINGLE BASEMENT LEVEL. THE BUILDING IS INTENDED TO BE A RESTAURANT. THE FUTURE INTERIOR FIT-OUT WILL BE PERMITTED SEPARATELY.
1331 4TH ST SE   
03/30/15 
FC 1331 LLC / OTIS ELEVATOR COMPANY
EN1501335 / SHOP DRAWING
TYPE OF ELEVATOR : ONE (1) TRACTION / STEEL / CENTRAL / VERTICAL TRANSPOTATION LICENSE NUMBER : ELC1300386 ISSUE DATE : 08 / 04 / 2014 EXPIRATION DATE 11-30-2015
909 HALF ST SE   
03/26/15 
23 I LLC / WAYNE REEP; 23 I LLC; WAYNE REEP
E37408577 / SUPPLEMENTAL
1015 HALF ST SE   
03/27/15 
HALF ST SE LLC / JOSEPH J FLYNN
E1504436 / SUPPLEMENTAL
   
03/27/15 
HALF ST SE LLC / ROBERT L HUNTER
M1501489 / SUPPLEMENTAL
   
03/17/15 
BON CHON / PHILIP GODAIRE; BON CHON; PHILIP GODAIRE
P42469697 / SUPPLEMENTAL
   
03/17/15 
EVAN OBRIEN / JOSEPH ABRESCH; EVAN OBRIEN; ROBERT HUNSBERGER
E74054014 / SUPPLEMENTAL
   
03/25/15 
HALF ST SE LLC / GEORGE DELGADO
B1501688 / CONSTRUCTION
INTERIOR ALTERATION TO 3 4 5 FLOORS AND PARTIAL 6TH FLOOR. WORK TO INCLUDE ELECTRICAL MECHANICAL AND PLUMBING
   
03/25/15 
SAM HOLLEN / GARY MCVEY; SAM HOLLEN; GARY MCVEY
E58849835 / SUPPLEMENTAL
82 I ST SE   
03/17/15 
CSX TRANSPORTATION INC / MITCH A. PERMUY
E1504130 / SUPPLEMENTAL
100 I ST SE   
03/26/15 
NA NA NA
EHOP1590452 / HOME OCCUPATION
300 M ST SE   
03/13/15 
FEDERAL CENTER LP / GREGORY E LIGON
E1504060 / SUPPLEMENTAL
250 M ST SE   
03/12/15 
DAN MCCABE / MICHAEL YASEK
SB1500183 / CONSTRUCTION
FIVE 70-FOOT GEOTECHNICAL SPT SOIL BORINGS WILL BE PERFORMED WITH AN AUGER DRILLING RIG UTILIZING CONTINUOUS FLIGHT HOLLOW STEM AUGERS CREATING APPROXIMATELY 6-INCH DIAMETER BOREHOLES.
909 NEW JERSEY AVE SE   
03/16/15 
909 NEW JERSEY AVENUE ACQUISITION LLC / DENNIS LEE WINDSOR
M1501348 / SUPPLEMENTAL
ONE UNIT IS A 10 TON UNIT AND 2 ADDITIONAL UNITS ARE 7.5TONS
   
03/17/15 
909 NEW JERSEY AVENUE ACQUISITION LLC / DAVID L. HAHN
P1504255 / SUPPLEMENTAL
1000 NEW JERSEY AVE SE   
03/14/15 
PHILIP BROWN
PC93167082 / POST CARD
REPLACEMENT OF NOT MORE THAN 1 GAS APPLIANCE ON A RESIDENTIAL COMMERCIAL OR INDUSTRIAL PROJECT.
1111 NEW JERSEY AVE SE   
03/19/15 
NJA ASSOCIATES LLC / THOMAS P MCGUIRE
E1504215 / SUPPLEMENTAL
   
03/30/15 
GALLERY CAPITOL RIVERFRONT / THOMAS P MCGUIRE
E1504472 / SUPPLEMENTAL
25 POTOMAC AVE SE   
03/18/15 
RIVERFRONT HOLDINGS I LLC / GLENNWOOD ROGERS
P1504172 / SUPPLEMENTAL
301 WATER ST SE   
03/13/15 
FOREST CITY / FVI 2020
TL1500054 / CONSTRUCTION
NEW RESTAURANT TENANT LAYOUT AT THE LUMBER SHED PARCEL FOR AN OYSTER BAR WITH 55 INTERIOR SEATS (55 AT 1ST LEVEL AND 30 AT MEZZANINE) 10 STAFF AND 38 OUTDOOR SUMMER GARDEN SEATING.
   
03/13/15 
FC LUMBER SHED LLC / FLACK
TL1500055 / CONSTRUCTION
FULL SERVICE RESTAURANT LOCATED ON THE GROUND FLOOR WITH A TOTAL NUMBER OF SEATS OF 170. INDOORS SEATING IS 86 OUTDOORS SEATING IS 84 ALL OUTDOOR SEATS ARE LOCATED ON PRIVATE PROPERTY. TOTAL OCCUPANT LOAD OF 189 WHICH INCLUDES 19 STAFF.
   
03/18/15 
FC LUMBER SHED LLC / SEAN O JOHN
P1504295 / SUPPLEMENTAL
   
03/19/15 
FC LUMBER SHED LLC / DONALD V. ELLENBERGER
M1501405 / SUPPLEMENTAL
   
03/20/15 
LUMBER SHED LIC / ROBERT WATTS; LUMBER SHED LIC; ROBERT WATTS
E99575145 / SUPPLEMENTAL
AH = After Hours; B = Alteration & Repair; D = Demolition; E = Electrical; FB = Boiler; M = Mechanical; P = Plumbing and Gas; PC = Post Card; R = Raze; SG = Sign; TL = Tenant Layout; TN = Tent; RW = Retaining Wall;

Real Property Sales Archive  
1201 HALF ST SE   02/19/15
$ 9,000,000
WEST HALF RESIDENTIAL II LLC
 
N ST SE   02/19/15
$ 36,000,000
WEST HALF RESIDENTIAL III LLC
 
0038 N ST SE   02/19/15
$ 36,000,000
WEST HALF RESIDENTIAL III LLC
 
0036 N ST SE   02/19/15
$ 36,000,000
WEST HALF RESIDENTIAL III LLC
 
R N ST SE   02/19/15
$ 36,000,000
WEST HALF RESIDENTIAL III LLC
 
0030 N ST SE   02/19/15
$ 36,000,000
WEST HALF RESIDENTIAL III LLC
 
0032 N ST SE   02/19/15
$ 36,000,000
WEST HALF RESIDENTIAL III LLC
 
N ST SE   02/19/15
$ 36,000,000
WEST HALF RESIDENTIAL III LLC
 
1275 HALF ST   02/19/15
$ 36,000,000
WEST HALF RESIDENTIAL III LLC
 
HALF ST   02/19/15
$ 36,000,000
WEST HALF RESIDENTIAL III LLC
 
M ST   02/19/15
$ 36,000,000
WEST HALF RESIDENTIAL III LLC
 
1ST ST SE   02/10/15
$ 1,913,472
BALLPARK HOTEL LLC
 
1ST ST SE   02/10/15
$ 1,913,472
BALLPARK HOTEL LLC
 
1ST ST SE   02/10/15
$ 1,913,472
BALLPARK HOTEL LLC
 
1ST ST SE   02/10/15
$ 6,600,000
BALLPARK RESIDENTIAL LLC
 
1ST ST SE   02/10/15
$ 6,600,000
BALLPARK RESIDENTIAL LLC
 
1ST ST SE   02/10/15
$ 6,600,000
BALLPARK RESIDENTIAL LLC
 
1ST ST SE   02/10/15
$ 6,600,000
BALLPARK RESIDENTIAL LLC
 


Project Directory




     © Copyright 2015 JD.